Senator Jim DeMint Reports On Honduras

2009 October 10
by INC

I saw Senator DeMint discussing his visit to Honduras on FOX last week.  He has an editorial in today’s Wall Street Journal (via Hot Air) in which he verifies what all of us who were reading the facts and paying attention knew:  there was no “coup”; Zelaya was a corrupt man whose efforts to retain power by changing the Honduran constitution were illegal while his removal from the presidency was legal and constitutional.  Senator DeMint did mention some items that were new to me:

What I Heard in Honduras

In a day packed with meetings, we met only one person in Honduras who opposed Mr. Zelaya’s ouster, who wishes his return, and who mystifyingly rejects the legitimacy of the November elections: U.S. Ambassador Hugo Llorens.

When I asked Ambassador Llorens why the U.S. government insists on labeling what appears to the entire country to be the constitutional removal of Mr. Zelaya a “coup,” he urged me to read the legal opinion drafted by the State Department’s top lawyer, Harold Koh. As it happens, I have asked to see Mr. Koh’s report before and since my trip, but all requests to publicly disclose it have been denied.

On the other hand, the only thorough examination of the facts to date—conducted by a senior analyst at the Law Library of Congress—confirms the legality and constitutionality of Mr. Zelaya’s ouster. (It’s on the Internet here .)

You probably remember the controversy surrounding Harold Koh. Hot Air links to acid commentary by Andy McCarthy at The Corner.

…As Ed Whelan and I pointed out when Koh was up for confirmation, the former Yale Law School dean is the nation’s leading transnationalist. He has zero respect for national constitutions (including ours), preferring a post-sovereign order in which international law profs, transnational organizations, and free-lancing judges will be our overlords. What is happening with Honduras is exactly what anyone who familiarized himself with Koh’s record would have predicted. Yet, he was confirmed by a 62-35 margin, with support from the usual GOP suspects:  Lugar, Voinovich, Snowe, Collins, and Martinez.

Will these Republicans who helped foist Koh on us now join others demanding that President Transparency release Koh’s legal opinion on Honduras? (I won’t ask about the 19 Republican Senators who thought Holder would be a fabulous, non-political Attorney General …)

Senator DeMint challenges the Obama administration with a very pointed conclusion:

America’s Founding Fathers—like the framers of Honduras’s own constitution—believed strong institutions were necessary to defend freedom and democracy from the ambitions of would-be tyrants and dictators. Faced by Mr. Zelaya’s attempted usurpations, the institutions of Honduran democracy performed as designed, and as our own Founding Fathers would have hoped.

Hondurans are therefore left scratching their heads. They know why Hugo Chávez, Daniel Ortega and the Castro brothers oppose free elections and the removal of would-be dictators, but they can’t understand why the Obama administration does.

They’re not the only ones.

__________
H/T: Hot Air, Wall Street Journal, The Corner.

21 Responses leave one →
  1. 2009 October 10 11:53 am
    [1]
    rightwingyahoo permalink

    Honduras will hold a new election early next year, and by then Zelaya will be a distant memory.

    Did you see Argentina pass a bill limiting free speech? They call it “democratizing” free speech. Meaning the 50% plus one can trample and wipe out the rights of the other 50%-1….

    Look for that here, soon.

    Something wicked this way comes….

  2. 2009 October 10 12:21 pm
    [2]
    justrand permalink

    rwy: “Honduras will hold a new election early next year, and by then Zelaya will be a distant memory.”

    Actually the election is Noverber 29…a little over a month away. And OUR Ambassabor is NOT supporting it! Something wicked is already there…look for the Communist thugs to try and de-ligitimize the election, and for Obama to side with the thugs!

    and as for Free Speech here being curtailed…THAT will be here very soon now I fear. It will have all kinds of different names:
    - Hate Speech elimination
    - Diversity
    - “Calming the National Discourse”
    - and some CRISIS! that requires a “temporary” suspension of the Internet and of assembly

    Sooner or later…but I think sooner.

  3. 2009 October 10 12:26 pm
    [3]
    rightwingyahoo permalink

    Oops, my bad on the election date.

    For the Obama administration to actually try to subvert the election process and install someone who is not eligible to hold the office again, would be something else to behold.

    I wonder what the domestic reaction would be among our electorate?

  4. 2009 October 10 12:29 pm
    [4]
    janzam permalink

    Nice post INC. Am glad to see your SN on BJG again!

    Hondurans are therefore left scratching their heads. …as are most Americans who see this great divide between the Obama Administration and the Honduran government.

    When did it become “American” to salute and support the “bad guys?”

    No one gets this Presidency except the elites inside government calling the shots!

  5. 2009 October 10 12:36 pm
    [5]
    INC permalink

    Thanks, Jan!

    The continuing actions and rhetoric from the White House have been both ridiculous and outrageous. There is no way to justify putting Zelaya back in and using it as a threat not to recognize the Honduran elections.

    Florida Republicans U.S. Reps. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Lincoln Diaz-Balart and Mario Diaz-Balart returned from Honduras Tuesday and said that the major presidential candidates there want the elections to go ahead, with U.S. support….

    Ros-Lehtinen reiterated the view that Zelaya should not be reinstated.

    “My meetings with civil society leaders and officials in the Honduran government have further convinced me that Zelaya’s return to power would only serve to endanger U.S. security interests, undermine the legitimacy of the Honduran constitution, and jeopardize the future of freedom and democracy in Honduras and throughout the region,” she said in a statement.

  6. 2009 October 10 12:40 pm
    [6]
    INC permalink

    Koh’s cover up on the legal analysis is also outrageous. I’m sure it would not bear the light of day and decent thinking critique, but would instigate a hue and cry if realized. That’s why it is under wraps. IMHO.

  7. 2009 October 10 12:56 pm
    [7]

    Thanks for highlighting this issue, it’s rather shocking to me most the Old Media and New media for that matter are largely ignoring this story. It’s one of the most telling FP moves dipchit has made and continues to make yet.

  8. 2009 October 10 1:41 pm
    [8]
    drdog09 permalink

    Here’s the Peace Dividend –

    [Economist Heidi] Shierholz said the economy faces a “jobs gap” of almost 10 million — the 7.2 million jobs lost plus the roughly 125,000 per month that would have been needed since the recession began just to keep up with population growth.

    To close that gap and get back to pre-recession levels in two years would require more than 500,000 new jobs per month, a pace of job creation that hasn’t been seen since 1950-51, Shierholz said.

    Most analysts expect the nation to keep losing jobs through this year and the unemployment rate to peak above 10 percent by the middle of next year, even as the economy starts to recover.

    Not like we did not know it already. According to the same economist, there are now 6.3 Americans competing for every job out there. How times change. Now it is ’scrounging for every job that Americans can find.’

  9. 2009 October 10 1:44 pm
    [9]
    drdog09 permalink

    Tuscon Teas fill a local stadium.

    HT: Instapundit.

  10. 2009 October 10 1:52 pm
    [10]
    drdog09 permalink

    Last rant of the day –

    “The communications between the agencies and telecommunications companies regarding the immunity provisions of the proposed legislation have been regarded as intra-agency because the government and the companies have a common interest in the defense of the pending litigation and the communications regarding the immunity provisions concerned that common interest.”

    Another words the govt is in court advocating that the Telcos are an arm of the government!

    Link.

  11. 2009 October 10 1:54 pm
    [11]
    JustMary permalink

    INC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

  12. 2009 October 10 2:25 pm
    [12]
    fedupartist permalink

  13. 2009 October 10 2:35 pm
    [13]
    justrand permalink

    OT, hattip Powerline:
    Aftenposten is the largest paper in Norway. A poll they conducted found that 62% of Aftenposten’s readers felt Obama did NOT deserve the prize. 37% voted yes.

    And the Swede’s next door consider the whole thing more evidence of Norwegian stooopidity!

    Oh, and this cartoon is AWESOME…

  14. 2009 October 10 2:53 pm
    [14]
    INC permalink

    KH, I kind of expected the Old Media to ignore this while shilling for Obama. I agree that it’s been shocking the extent to which it’s been ignored by much of the New Media as Obama really revealed himself with his policy and reaction to the Hondurans.

    It was good that DeMint and others went down to Honduras–it gave them added authority to speak.

    Hey, JM! :-)

  15. 2009 October 10 2:54 pm
    [15]
    INC permalink

    Artist & JR–funny!!

  16. 2009 October 10 3:54 pm
    [16]
    bc3b permalink

    DeMint is one of few Republicans in Congress with any courage. John Kerry tried to do everything in his power to stop this trip to Honduras.

  17. 2009 October 10 4:25 pm
    [17]

    Perhaps Demint should note Honduras is a “teachable moment”, and invite Obama to have a beer with himself and Micheletti. :)

  18. 2009 October 10 4:40 pm
    [18]
    justrand permalink

    yup, KH, ya gotta have a gimmick if you want to catch the eye of the Chosen One. Maybe he could tell our Dear Leader it’s a Nobel cause? A case of Noblesse Oblige?

  19. 2009 October 10 4:44 pm
    [19]
    mulletover permalink

    John Hinderaker at PowerLine does a fine job of slicing and dicing the political decision of the Nobel committee.

    http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2009/10/024672.php

    It pretty much comes down to Obama’s apologies to the world as his main accomplishments.

    Guess that’s about right.

  20. 2009 October 10 7:09 pm
    [20]
    INC permalink

    Babalu Blog has this reminder (with a nice photo of Kerry!):

    Kerry himself visited Daniel Ortega to condemn Reagan’s Central American policy and warmly chum it up with the regime whose national anthem regards the U.S. as “el enemigo de la humanidad!“(the enemy of humanity!”)

  21. 2009 October 10 7:32 pm
    [21]
    INC permalink

    Ed Whelan at The Corner:

    Miguel Estrada, who has explained in detail that the ouster of former Honduran president Manuel Zelaya was lawful, has passed along to me his judgment that the Law Library of Congress report [pdf] is “basically right.”

    On Koh, he quotes Estrada as writing:

    In a democracy the [State Department] Legal Adviser ought not to write a secret analysis of publicly available documents solely because he does not have the gumption to expose his reasoning process and conclusions to public scrutiny.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.