So Let It Be Written, So Let It Be Over Ruled?

2014 December 16
by drdog09

Obviously this judge did not get the memo about not screwing around with The Won. —

Earlier Tuesday, a federal court in Pennsylvania declared aspects of President Obama’s executive actions on immigration policy unconstitutional.

According to the opinion by Judge Arthur Schwab, the president’s policy goes “beyond prosecutorial discretion” in that it provides a relatively rigid framework for considering applications for deferred action, thus obviating any meaningful case-by-case determination as prosecutorial discretion requires, and provides substantive rights to applicable individuals. As a consequence, Schwab concluded, the action exceeds the scope of executive authority.

This is the first judicial opinion to address Obama’s decision to expand deferred action for some individuals unlawfully present in the United States.


Course this will go to appeal. But it is interesting that it originated in the 1st District. Not quite as leftist as the 9th in Calif, but close.

This ruling does paint an interesting aspect on the Executive Branch ability to formulate moves irrespective of the law. The judge did not rule based on whether Obama could do this. He ruled on how he is going about it.

36 Responses leave one →
  1. 2014 December 16 12:10 pm
    bc3b permalink

    Football picks have been emailed. It appears I made a mistake on TLS’s picks, which is delaying the posting of standings but Mullet is riding my @$$.

  2. 2014 December 16 12:45 pm
    drdog09 permalink

    “…. but Mullet is riding my @$$.”

    Whoa, its spawning season already?

  3. 2014 December 16 12:46 pm
    bc3b permalink

    BJG NFL Standings

    NFL Division
    bc3b: 108-47/11-3
    Mullet: 105-50/12-2
    MI Conservative: 100-55/11-3
    Fight On: 100-55/12-2
    Justrand: 98-57/8-6
    RJH: 94-61/8-6
    TLS: 91-64/11-3

    I sent out two emails with this week’s games today. Please respond to the later one (from Thank you.

  4. 2014 December 16 1:57 pm
    mulletover permalink

    Mullets can’t ride @$$.

    But we might be slapping bc’s gravel, and clouding his judgement.

  5. 2014 December 16 2:11 pm

    The court ruling may be overridden, but we can enjoy a short Pyhrric victory nevertheless.

  6. 2014 December 16 3:20 pm
    mulletover permalink

    Will this ruling favorably impact the case moving forward brought by the 20 attorney generals? Perhaps that one will come at it from another direction.

    I think I recall there was hope for injunctive relief due to the vast impact this unconstitutional action has.

  7. 2014 December 16 4:59 pm
    justrand permalink

    Justice Roberts has his opening (when combined with the State AG actions) to fast track this to the Supreme Court.

    Will he?? Hmmm….

  8. 2014 December 16 5:17 pm

    Whatever he was blackmailed with the first time is still there methinks.

  9. 2014 December 16 5:32 pm

    A memoranda ruling has no force of law behind it. It is only a non binding opinion.

  10. 2014 December 16 5:55 pm
    drdog09 permalink

    For all his faults — — He does understand what it means to be American. Unlike the sniveling, back biting, race baiting, lump of flesh that pretends to be a pResident.

  11. 2014 December 16 6:02 pm
    drdog09 permalink

    Damn! — — And I thought I had given up voting for good….

  12. 2014 December 17 3:23 am

    8 – That’s rhetorical right?

    Between this and the tax payer responsibility for derivatives crap in crumulus … I mean what could go wrong?

  13. 2014 December 17 7:29 am
    drdog09 permalink

    UVA situation gets really weird — — Looks like `Jackie` was using a high school prank to try and make the object of her affections jealous.

  14. 2014 December 17 7:39 am
    justrand permalink

    drdog: “UVA situation gets really weird “

    you mean “weirdER

    but (as they say in the NFL) upon further review, the UVA situation is becoming the NORM. Anyone from the Left can make up ANYTHING and the “Fake, but accurate” stormtroopers will take over.

    The truth eventually comes out…but by then America is [yawn] sooooo tired of the story

  15. 2014 December 17 8:16 am
    justrand permalink

  16. 2014 December 17 9:20 am
    drdog09 permalink

    It appears that the Ominstration is preparing to normalize relations with Cuba. As heard on the radio.

    Expect MLB salaries to collapse.

  17. 2014 December 17 9:35 am

    Count fla. in the GOP column in 2016

  18. 2014 December 17 11:53 am
    mulletover permalink

    Maybe Cubans can now drive cars newer than 1957.

  19. 2014 December 17 4:27 pm
    justrand permalink

    Sony has pulled “The Interview”

    What PUSSIES

  20. 2014 December 17 4:57 pm


    Our modern edumakational system.

  21. 2014 December 17 4:58 pm

    20 so much for the 1st amend. If it was amovie critical of a “right winger” they wouldn’t have pulled it.

  22. 2014 December 17 7:46 pm
    drdog09 permalink

    “No one should kid themselves. With the Sony collapse America has lost its first cyberwar. This is a very very dangerous precedent.” == Newt Gingrich.

    Lets say Gingrich is right. The question then arises, what was in the `Christmas Bombshell`? What could Sony have been doing that could lead to national security issues? Who would be the target of such a disclosure?

    In a less racially infused world an inquiring US AG would consider this whole affair worth of effort.

  23. 2014 December 17 8:19 pm
    mulletover permalink

    Not sure this isn’t a hoax cooked up by the obama administration and hollywood for some nefarious reason, net neutrality, or who knows what.

  24. 2014 December 18 6:17 am
    drdog09 permalink

    Hope n’ Change? — — Gabby Giffords old seat in AZ is won by a gun tote’n GOPer.

  25. 2014 December 18 7:32 am

    feel good post of the day.

  26. 2014 December 18 7:43 am
    justrand permalink

    Drdog, Ron Barber tried EVERY Dem vote manufacturing trick he could…but when they were rejected he lost. There’s a lesson there somewhere. Maybe if the rest of the GOP would fight like McSally!

  27. 2014 December 18 8:18 am


  28. 2014 December 18 10:17 am


  29. 2014 December 18 10:28 am
    drdog09 permalink


    Families are inherently socialist. Parents shared with their offspring and with each other the fruits of their labors. Love of family is the reason. But that does not translate into the larger world. Or as Mr. Sowell says — “Love does not scale.” We seem to have forgotten that lesson and it needs to be taught again.

  30. 2014 December 18 10:42 am

    The eyes of texas be upon ye.

  31. 2014 December 18 2:57 pm

    post 31


    Paramount has ordered them not to show it.

  32. 2014 December 18 5:27 pm

    Still a few sane ones left it seems.

  33. 2014 December 18 6:52 pm
    justrand permalink

    Fuck Paramount..Sony…and all of Hollywood, for tht matter

  34. 2014 December 18 7:00 pm
    drdog09 permalink

    So this is where we are at in society — — a woman screams rape and the guy could go to jail. This tho, the dude had it all on tape.

    I don’t know what the three of them were up to, but it certainly looks like a setup.

  35. 2014 December 18 7:18 pm
    drdog09 permalink

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.