“A campus is not the place for free speech”

2019 April 8
by bc3b

Not surprisingly. that bit of “wisdom” comes from an East Coast liberal arts college president.

President Trump recently signed a Presidential Order regarding freedom of speech on college campuses.

Unfortunately, there are college presidents, like David R. Harris, who oppose it because it doesn’t fit with their goal of political indoctrination.

By the way, Union College is located in Schenectady, New York. Tuition, fees, room and board amount to $68,000. Yet, it has a rather low (38%) acceptance rate, so students are anxious to join the 2,200 student body.

Who, in their right mind, would want to pay $68,000 attend a liberal arts college in Schenectady? Schenectady is the former home of General Electric. Its population peaked at 91,000 in 1950 and is 66,000 today. It has one of the highest per capita crime rates in the US. Only 56% of Schenectady high school students graduate. Yes, it’s a virtual paradise.

It’s amazing that over-priced, private liberal arts colleges like Union continue to exist. But, fast food chains and retailers need to get employees from somewhere.

Union College President David R. Harris recently penned an argument against free speech on college campuses, claiming that institutions of higher learning have a responsibility to manage speech by providing “constructive engagement,” so that students can have an optimal learning experience.

Union College president David R. Harris penned an op-ed, entitled, “A Campus Is Not the Place for Free Speech,” in which he argues that it is the role of colleges and universities to filter the conversations on campuses to provide “constructive engagement.”

“I oppose free speech on college campuses,” states Harris in his op-ed, “I think college campuses should be safe havens from voices on the left and right that violate what I have learned and what I believe.”

The college president had written his op-ed in response to President Donald Trump’s recent executive order requiring colleges and universities to uphold the First Amendment on campus in order to continue receiving federal research funding.

“Many of the president’s supporters have applauded his free speech decision,” states Harris, “because they argue that higher education institutions trumpet liberal perspectives and silence conservative voices.” Harris adds that members of academia believe “the president and his supporters do not understand what actually happens on college campuses.”

Harris also claims  in his op-ed that institutions of higher learning would only be managing speech on campus for students’ own good, suggesting that when left unchecked, free speech would not facilitate a productive learning experience, arguing that individuals will end up using speech irresponsibly when utilizing it in its “purest form”

“Free speech, in its purest form, is an exercise in what is achieved when a person yells a view and then leaves, after which someone with an opposing perspective does the same” states the college president, “The speakers do not grow as a result of the experience, and the audience has no opportunity to probe the opposing points of view.”

Harris also insists that he is a supporter of free speech, but just not when it comes to college campuses. On campuses, Harris says, “we must strive for something more than free speech.”

“It is not enough for individuals to speak freely,” continues Harris, adding that college students are already having more constructive and diverse interactions than “most adults,” claiming, “college campuses and social networks tend to be more diverse than ‘real world’ neighborhoods and social clubs.”

One could argue, however, that younger generations today seem to be less tolerant of everything from intellectually diverse conversations, to even lighthearted comedy skits.

Hat tip: Breitbart

28 Responses leave one →
  1. 2019 April 8 9:10 pm
    [1]
    justrand permalink

    Bc3b wins it all!

    Congrats!

    TLS’ young lad came in second…congrats to him too!

    Mrs. JR takes home the coveted ‘Anchor Award’…um, congrats…I guess

  2. 2019 April 9 5:01 am
    [2]
    bc3b permalink

    Congratulations Austin. Virginia got a lot of help from the refs.

  3. 2019 April 9 5:44 am
    [3]
    drdog09 permalink

    One of the problems with defending free speech is you often have to defend people that you find to be outrageous and unpleasant and disgusting.

    — Salman Rushdie

    Yep, like the dipshit quoted in this post.

  4. 2019 April 9 5:52 am
    [4]
    drdog09 permalink

  5. 2019 April 9 5:56 am
    [5]
    drdog09 permalink

  6. 2019 April 9 5:56 am
    [6]
    TLS permalink

    Congrats bc!!

    So proud of my kid. He finished second at the top and I finished second at the bottom!

  7. 2019 April 9 6:04 am
    [7]
    TLS permalink

    The mass exodus of R’s not seeking re-election in the last midterm comes a little more into the light. Bold is mine:

    https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/04/08/fitton-obama-state-dept-conspiracy-against-trump/

    And then they released more heavily redacted State documents showing classified information was desperately sent to multiple U.S. Senators by the Obama administration immediately prior to President Donald Trump’s inauguration. The documents reveal that among those receiving the classified documents were Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA), Sen. Ben Cardin (D-MD), and Sen. Robert Corker (R-TN).

  8. 2019 April 9 6:12 am
    [8]
    justrand permalink

    from the article:
    ==> “Because nothing says freedom quite like forcing people to join a union against their will.”

    https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2019/04/sanders_calls_for_federal_ban_on_right_to_work_laws.html#ixzz5kbSh0RY7

  9. 2019 April 9 6:20 am
    [9]
    justrand permalink

    “A campus is not the place for free speech” reminded me of this this clip from ‘Dr. Stranglove’.

    You can’t fight in here. This is the WAR Room!

  10. 2019 April 9 6:33 am
    [10]
    justrand permalink

    drdog, Chicago only ranks down where it is because they consider the entire Chicago area. But the South side of Chicago is a nightly war-zone, which easily outpaces everywhere else.

    again, the common denominator is long-term Democrat rule

  11. 2019 April 9 6:52 am
    [11]
    bc3b permalink

    drdog09 #4

    The Detroit Thugs and Motown Muggers were sickened when they saw how Detroit fell in terms of crime. Two of the Muggers were in tears. They have vowed to correct this travesty.

  12. 2019 April 9 6:54 am
    [12]
    bc3b permalink

    JR –

    Chicago’s west side is giving the south side a run for its money in terms of crime. The only safe places within the city are the north side and The Loop (unless you are Jussie Smollott).

    Chicago also has a much larger illegal alien population than most other Midwest cities like Detroit, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Indianapolis, St. Louis, etc. Expect major turf battles between black and Hispanic gangs in a few years.

  13. 2019 April 9 8:28 am
    [13]
    bc3b permalink

  14. 2019 April 9 8:40 am
    [14]
    bc3b permalink

    Francis (aka Beto) asks Iowa farmers to give up share of crops for climate change:

    https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/04/08/robert-beto-orourke-to-farmers-give-fair-share-of-crops-for-climate-change/

    Francis: perhaps a better solution might be for the elitist climate warriors to fly commercial rather than personal or chartered jets to the next “Save the World” confab.

  15. 2019 April 9 8:55 am
    [15]
    bc3b permalink

    Alabama Teacher Killed in Accident Caused by Illegal after Judge Delayed Deportation:

    http://borderpac.org/news/illegal-alien-kills-beloved-alabama-schoolteacher/

    Is this part of the riches that Francis the Marxist says migrants always bring:

    https://www.breitbart.com/immigration/2019/04/07/pope-francis-praises-multiculturalism-migrants-always-bring-riches/

  16. 2019 April 9 8:56 am
    [16]
    drdog09 permalink

    14,j

    Paging Dr. Harper, Dr. Harper please report to the podium…..

    I have a bet for the Democrats. I will pay your dane geld. BUT if on year 13 climate calamity has not ensued I get all my money back with 14% interest AND you disband the Democratic party. I can put the contract together for you in no time, you game??

  17. 2019 April 9 9:09 am
    [17]

    The perfect dem ticket~~~Biden/Beto. The elder gentleman appeals to the old school dems, the younger arm waving kennedyesque pseudo beaner appeals to the younger bomb throwers. A ticket made in hell. They fail to see that mixing shit ( Beto) with perceived ice cream (Biden) still doesn’t improve on the diversity milkshake.

  18. 2019 April 9 10:16 am
    [18]
    drdog09 permalink

    $15/hrx0hrs=$0Gross pay

    I think I could have a little fun. I could be wrong but I assume the robot sees an empty shelf spot scans either the shelf tag or uses GPS and a data table to place the reorder. So what would happen to WallyWorlds inventory if customers walked in and just shifted product over one spot on the shelf? Or down a row to fill the blank spot but leave a new blank causing reorder. Might be as much fun as eating Tide pods.

  19. 2019 April 9 10:27 am
    [19]
    drdog09 permalink

    BC,

    I think we are missing a whole new category — https://www.qwant.com/?q=grid%20girls&t=images — So when is the Indy500 this year???

  20. 2019 April 9 10:44 am
    [20]
    justrand permalink

    as long as we’re talking about cars, racing or otherwise, we should all remember that proper maintenance is soooo important…as is keeping your vehicles clean!!

    here’s some helpful tips on proper washing of your car…courtesy of ‘Cool Hand Luke’

  21. 2019 April 9 10:53 am
    [21]
    bc3b permalink

    drdog09 #19 –

    Thanks for the suggestion, but I think the hot girls in racing is a European, Asian, Australian thing. The only hot women at the Indy 500 are in the grandstand.

    https://www.google.com/search?q=hot+women+of+the+indy+500&tbm=isch&source=iu&ictx=1&fir=pTs25NwKniLQ9M%253A%252CbzYwSySbdU4PqM%252C_&vet=1&usg=AI4_-kTCsU_OxsmhKxYUDWW6MeZEp_l7dQ&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwimkq-OycPhAhUHd6wKHe3PC5UQ9QEwAHoECAoQBA#imgrc=pTs25NwKniLQ9M:

  22. 2019 April 9 1:08 pm
    [22]
    JimNorCal permalink

    Reasonable punishment? Or the case only brought because it gave state of WA a chance to help illegals?
    Motel 6 Will Pay $12 Million for Sharing Guest Data with Immigration
    (April 5, 2019)
    Motel 6 has been ordered to pay the US State of Washington US $12 million for sharing guest information with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) without first receiving a warrant. While the lawsuit was filed in Washington state, the practice occurred across the country. Most of the money will be shared among the 80,000 people whose privacy was violated. Motel 6 has signed a legally binding agreement stating that it will not share guest information without a warrant, a subpoena, or a credible reason to believe an individual is in danger.

    Read more in:
    http://www.seattletimes.com: Motel 6 to pay Washington $12M for giving information on 80,000 guests to ICE
    http://www.scmagazine.com: Motel 6 to pay $12M for sharing guest info with ICE
    – agportal-s3bucket.s3.amazonaws.com: State of Washington, Plaintiff, v. Motel 6 Operating L.P. And G6 Hospitality LLC: Consent Decree (PDF)

  23. 2019 April 9 3:34 pm
    [23]
    fight on permalink

  24. 2019 April 9 3:35 pm
    [24]
    fight on permalink

  25. 2019 April 9 4:31 pm
    [25]
    drdog09 permalink

    Why does a government unwilling to defend its borders spend $1,000 billion annually on defense?
    — Paul Roberts

  26. 2019 April 9 5:00 pm
    [27]
    justrand permalink

    Drdog, in re. #26 above…

    At least once a week the A/P, NYT, CNN or other fake news outlet comes out with story of a “Republican” who sadly laments: “the Republican Party left ME, I didn’t leave THEM”.

    Ah gee…so sad. They never get around to telling us what the “final straw” was. Was it:
    – when Republicans vehemently opposed the “new” Democrat support for UNLIMITED abortion up to and INCLUDING birth?
    – when Republicans (okay, Trump) tried to wake the nation up the REAL CRISIS at our Southern Border and [gasp] vowed to DEFEND our country?
    – when Republicans tried to oppose the Obamacare mandate that nuns must hand out abortifacients, and MEN must be allowed to shower with little girls?
    – or when Republicans declared the Bill of Rights to be INVIOLATE…and thus not subject to the whims of Leftist “judges”

    I’d sure like to know

  27. 2019 April 9 5:06 pm
    [28]
    drdog09 permalink

    27,

    A series of questions that deserve answers.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.